Egregious: My Review of The Seeker. Warning: ENTIRELY Spoilers.

I’m watching The Seeker and I have to share my pain, so I am live-blogging my critique.

1) Casting Ian McShane as Merriman is like casting Jonathan Taylor Thomas as Indiana Jones. So wrong.

2) Why is everyone American? In this so called British school? Why does Will have to be 14? What was wrong with 11? And who’s the guy on the scaffolding watching the ‘Stantons’?

3) Max is in art school, you blasphemers!

4) WTF? The guy on the scaffolding is George Dawson? They are HIGH Also, apparently, he’s…Scottish? At least Northern somewhere. And John Smith isn’t a smith. In fact, it appears that there will be no discussion of the Old Ways or any background that might accidentally allude to British legend.

5) Where’s Annoying Sister Mary? Instead there’s someone named Gwen. Younger, not older. And a brunette.

6) Oh, Stephen’s on the webcam. Right. Oh, in Hawaii? Not, in fact, Jamaica. And I can’t help but notice he sent a belt instead of a fricking carnival head!

7) Overloading the crow imagery. But then, they took all the mythic resonance out, they had to have something.

8) Shopping Mall: Mysterious box with swirls? Shoplifting accusations? Dungeons? Are those guards…birdmen? This is certainly a radical departure from anything Susan Cooper wrote.

9) Will’s dad is a teacher? What was wrong with him being a jeweler?

10) What’s with the mysterious Celtic swirlies at Huntercombe Manor?

11) Betcha five bucks the Highschool Hottie takes the place of apple-cheeked Maggie, and is a vessel for the Dark.

12) Why is The Rider on a white horse? With black mastiffs?

13) Pretty good info-dump on why Will has to seek the signs. But where’s the Book of Gramarye? For that matter, where’s Hawkin?

14) Wait, he Googles Light and Dark? Oh, come on, people. And then he goes to his dad for advice? Because that’s what 14-year-old boys always do when confronted by supernatural uber-battles.

15) Whhaaa! The Rider is masquerading as a doctor? AND he’s Christopher Eccleston? If there was a drinking game wherein I drank for every time I saw something that appalled me, I would be on the floor by now.

16) Um. Will’s dead twin was…actually kidnapped, according to this tripe. I blame The Dark.

17) How come the Rider can come into church? Isn’t the sanctuary…well, a sanctuary? And how does he have a mother who is actually a crazy-mad snake lady?

18) The Lady is taking all too active a part. Where’s the ethereal? Where’s the Summer Queen? Oh. Right. They weren’t doing that. Now she’s a septuagenarian ninja

19) Bet: Five bucks says Will contains the Sixth Sign.

20) Wahey! Won five bucks: Highschool Hottie is in service to the Dark!

21) What’s with the midnight chat about his issues with Merriman? This Will Stanton is a totally different personality to Will in the book. And the setting the tree on fire? Yeah. Because the pyrotechnic budget wasn’t all used up.

22) Interesting step through time with little sister Gwen. This isn’t even embroidering on the book. It’s total fabrication and the adapters should call their mothers and confess their woeful inadequacies.

23) Wahaha! Rider possesses Max! And then 17th Century English Village cockfighting ensues. With Max still possessed! And Max dropped out of college! OMG! Why even say you’re adapting the book? Because…

24) Mr Stanton was working on some kind of Light and Dark Thesis? What was the point of that?

25) Manor crisis scene: Dramatic, but quite different from the book. Water indicates thaw, whereas the relentless cold imagery in the book is much more effective as ice and snow. Oooh, Highschool Hottie is named Maggie, as an homage to the book character. Way to be faithful scriptwriters!

26) Wait, what’s this? Will’s testing scene (at the beginning of the book) is now at the end of the movie? He hears his family’s voices and wavers? What’s this? He’s let the Rider in! The moron. OMG! And The Rider has Will’s twin brother! But here’s Merriman, going after the Rider with a mace! And The Rider consigns the twin to drowning! But then Old George comes out and he’s back in the fight!

27) Will makes a last stand against the Rider. SURPRISE! Five bucks for me, Will is the sixth sign. And surprise! The kidnapped twin gets to go home with Will!

Addendum notes: No Wild Hunt. No Arthur. No real ties to the book at all.

But not a bad movie. Generally speaking. For Hollywood’s blasphemous interpretation of this story, anyhow.

13 Comments to “Egregious: My Review of The Seeker. Warning: ENTIRELY Spoilers.”

  1. By erin, March 29, 2008 @ 11:09 pm

    I reread all these books recently when I saw that they were making the movie, but I knew that I wouldn’t want to see the movie because it would be all wrong. And those books are pure awesome.

  2. By Liz, March 29, 2008 @ 11:13 pm

    Exactly, Erin.

  3. By rachel, March 30, 2008 @ 6:56 am

    I will never be able to see this movie. You’ve taken a bullet for us, Liz.

  4. By Liz, March 30, 2008 @ 10:26 am

    This would be a good movie to see only if you want to be reduced to gibbering rage, Rachel.

  5. By cheesefairy, March 30, 2008 @ 12:22 pm

    I have absolutely no idea what you are talking about. (not familiar with the book[s] I mean) Nevertheless, this post cracked me the hell up. Having no context at all, I especially enjoyed points (6) and (12). Good questions, both.

    maybe they’re Americans in a British school for the same reason that people from Europe are always portrayed with British accents in film. For example, when the Nazis sound like the Queen.

  6. By Liz, March 30, 2008 @ 1:39 pm

    Cheesefairy, they are Americans because the Hollywood Machine sucks like a black hole.

    The book is awesome. Actually, the series is pretty damn good.

  7. By gen, March 30, 2008 @ 5:02 pm

    I almost cried when I heard that they were going to do the a movie and set it in the States. I was so angry at Cooper for allowing it – or whoever it was that gave permission.

  8. By stephanie, March 31, 2008 @ 7:37 pm

    I don’t know this book either…but…I think that Americans ruin everything. So it makes sense to me we would ruin this as well.

    And yes! Why DO Nazi’s always have British accents? What is up with that nonense?

  9. By Liz, March 31, 2008 @ 10:46 pm

    Gen, it was set in England with American transplants. Some kind of exchange or something. Don’t watch it. It’ll hurt.

    Stephanie, I don’t think Americans ruin everything. I do think that People With Money make some tacky and ill-considered decisions. And that the Hollywood Machine has a lot of money. Oh. And ‘American Cheese’? It’s gross. But I don’t know who’s responsible for that.

  10. By rachel, April 1, 2008 @ 6:56 am

    I’m American, and I try to ruin everything, but I don’t always succeed. It’s much harder than you’d think!

  11. By elswhere, April 1, 2008 @ 8:07 am

    I am a lazy American so I only ruin small things in corners.

  12. By gen, April 1, 2008 @ 8:35 am

    Oh, well then, American transplants. It still is all wrong and I sadly will not go and see the movie. But the Golden Compass was good – right?

  13. By Liz, April 1, 2008 @ 8:02 pm

    Gen, they messed with the pacing somewhat, but it had the right feel.

    I’m a Canadian, and I ruin lots of things: dinner, childrens’ dreams, umbrellas.

Bad Behavior has blocked 156 access attempts in the last 7 days.